We are thrilled to announce a landmark victory at the Federal High Court (Suit No: FHC/L/CS/2389/25), where the Court upheld our firm’s suit against the Patents Registry, the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment, and the Attorney-General of the Federation, declaring the registration and issuance of certificates for Utility Models null and void.
In the course of proceedings, the Court dismissed the AGF’s preliminary objection, retaining the AGF as a necessary party to address key constitutional questions while the other respondents filed no defense.
On the substantive suit, we contended that while a Bill seeking to incorporate Utility Models into Nigeria’s IP framework is pending before the National Assembly, until it is passed and assented to, the Registrar lacks the statutory power to register same. The Court agreed in its entirety, granting all reliefs sought and permanently restraining the Registrar from further registering Utility Models without legislative backing.
Addressing the unauthorized issuance of certificates based on unenacted bills, Hon. Justice Musa Kakaki held:
“Where [a] Certificate granted in respect of a Utility Model application was issued pursuant to a non-existing law, it is null and void and of no effect whatsoever as there was no legislation in operation empowering the Registrar to issue certificate of Utility Model in that behalf. Something cannot be placed on nothing and is expected to stand; it will certainly collapse.”
Emphasizing public accountability and statutory compliance, the Court further remarked:
“It calls into question the conduct of public officials who are not guided by or refuse to be guided by the provisions of the law. The provisions of the law are meant to be strictly followed and applied and not left to the whims and caprices of public officers.”
This decision brings much-needed clarity and certainty to the Nigerian intellectual property landscape, reinforcing that IP rights must remain strictly anchored on legislative enactment rather than administrative practice.
The team was led by our Partner, Oluwole Olukoya, MCArb and ably supported by Ayodele Osanyinbi.
As a foremost IP firm in Nigeria, we remain steadfast in upholding the integrity of IP practice and ensuring compliance with extant laws. Below is a Certified True Copy of the Judgement.